Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake

January 19, 2020

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake – tender and fluffy poppy seed cake layers with a grapefruit curd and cream cheese frosting.

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake #cakebycourtney #grapefruit #poppyseedcake #deliciouscake #cake

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake

Time for another cake update! This Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake has been on the blog for nearly four years and was in serious need of a makeover. And I’m not just talking pictures. The cake itself was super yummy, but after several more years of practicing and learning more about cakes, I knew it could be even better.

Poppy Seed Cake

The first set of changes I knew I needed to make were in the cake layers. While I liked the flavor and texture of the cake, I received comments and emails that some people struggled with getting a moist cake from this recipe. I’ll write another post about how to make sure you get moist cakes, but with this one, aside from watching the bake time, I knew that using all egg whites and the poppy seeds could be causing an issue.

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake #cakebycourtney #Grapefruitpoppyseedcake #poppyseedcake #curd #easycake #grapefruit #grapefruitdessert

When we only use egg whites in a cake, we risk getting a dry cake because there’s no fat from the yolks to help create moisture. However, sometimes we don’t want to add yolks because we want to keep the cake layers nice and white. So, we need to add fat somewhere else. Similar to my Champagne Cake, I ended up adding a cup of sour cream to this cake batter to ensure a super moist cake.

I had also read, after posting my initial recipe, that poppy seeds absorb moisture and can be a reason a poppy seed cake doesn’t taste moist. To make sure this doesn’t happen, you’ll just soak your poppy seeds in water for about 5 minutes. After they’re soaked, strain the excess water and mix them into the batter as instructed.

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake #cakebycourtney #Grapefruitpoppyseedcake #poppyseedcake #curd #easycake #grapefruit #grapefruitdessert

But, above all else, making sure you don’t over bake your cake layers is the sure-fire way to make sure you don’t end up with a dry cake. Keep your eye on your cake layers toward the end of the bake time. And remember, when you insert a toothpick in the center of the cake, it SHOULD come out with a few moist crumbs on it.

Grapefruit Curd

Next up, the grapefruit curd. Have you ever made grapefruit curd? It sounds like most people haven’t, but I’m about to change your world. If you love a lemon or citrus curd of any kind, you’ll love this tart, sweet grapefruit curd.

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake #cakebycourtney #Grapefruitpoppyseedcake #poppyseedcake #curd #easycake #grapefruit #grapefruitdessert

Making homemade curd is incredibly simple. You’ll start by mixing sugar, corn starch and salt in a sauce pan. After those dry ingredients are mixed well, you’ll then add the grapefruit juice and begin to cook the mixture over medium heat. As the mixture cooks, it will thicken a bit. When this happens, it’s time to add the egg yolks. The key here is to make sure you temper the eggs so we don’t cook them into scrambled eggs when we add the hot juice mixture. In the instructions you’ll notice that we take out a little of the hot juice and add it to the yolks while stirring quickly. After we’ve tempered the eggs like this, we can then add the egg mixture into the juice mixture and continue to cook. You’ll finish up the curd by adding butter and straining it through a mesh strainer.

The curd is a great element to make ahead of time. You can store it in the fridge in an airtight container for a couple weeks.

TIP: for a true grapefruit color, add a bit of “soft pink” Americolor food gel to the curd at the end of the cooking process.

Cream Cheese Frosting

The cream cheese frosting on this cake creates an awesome culmination of flavors: sweet, tart and tangy!

Grapefruit Poppy Seed Cake #cakebycourtney #Grapefruitpoppyseedcake #poppyseedcake #curd #easycake #grapefruit #grapefruitdessert

I don’t use a ton of cream cheese in my cream cheese frosting because I think it can become too overpowering. Instead, I use just 4 ounces of cream cheese to give the buttercream a tangy flavor without it stealing the show.

Planning Tips

As you’re planning out the elements of this cake, here’s how I’d lay out the week:

  • Three days before you want to serve the cake, make the grapefruit curd. You’ll store the curd in an airtight container in the fridge until you’re ready to use it.
  • Two days before you want to serve the cake, make the cake layers. Once the layers are cooled, wrap each one in plastic wrap and freeze. Remove the layers from the freezer about an hour before you plan to stack and decorate the cake.
  • The day before you want to serve the cake, make the frosting. Once complete, store in an airtight container and refrigerate.
  • The day you plan to serve the cake, remove the frosting from the fridge a couple hours before you want to stack and decorate. Rebeat the frosting for a few minutes and then begin assembly.


Join the Conversation

  1. Can lemon juice be substituted in the cake and curd to make it lemon flavor instead?

      1. Is it a 1:1 substitute for grapefruit to lemon juice for the cake?. Can I use the lemon curd recipe from your lemon bar cake as a substitute? Thank you.

  2. This cake looks amazing! I was wondering if I could make this cake using 2 9in pans?

    1. Yes, just bake at 325 for a few minutes longer – about 10

  3. Stephanie says:

    5 stars
    Made this over the course of the day today as a distraction from social isolation. It. Is. In-cred-i-ble!!!

    1. I’m so glad you liked it!!

  4. Brooke nelson says:

    Hi Courtney! If I can’t get grapefruit juice can I use lemon juice and would I use the same amounts when substituting?

  5. Karasten says:

    Hello! This cake is delicious! Question…. when cooling in the pan, my cake layers pulled away from the pan towards the tom creating an inverted triangle look. I think I forgot to spray the pan again after placing the parchment. Would that have caused it or did I do something else wrong? Thanks! 🙂

    1. Make sure you spray next time. And then use a cake leveler to level off the tops of the cake!

  6. 4 stars
    These are so delicious! I cut the recipe in half and made it into cupcakes. A few tips:
    –Half the recipe made 13 cupcakes
    –Half the frosting recipe made way too much frosting, next time I’ll do 1/3 or even 1/4
    –I made the whole curd recipe because, I don’t know. But if I had known how much I’d have left over, I would have cut the curd into 1/3.
    –I didn’t have any cream, so I just used the equivalent volume of grapefruit juice. I can’t taste it, and I think it might be the reason my frosting is so soft, so I’d just leave the liquid out next time.
    Thanks for the recipe!

    1. I’m not a big buttercream fan. Is it possible to add more cream cheese? How much would you recommend?

      1. Sure, I would use less butter in that case and add maybe another 4 ounces cream cheese.

  7. Hi! This looks amazing!! I was just wondering if you think blood orange could be substituted for the curd instead of grapefruit? Thanks!

  8. Super curious how you got the pink shade. Did you tint some of the frosting with gel then?

  9. matthew says:

    Made this but for cupcakes (about 24 @ 65g per) and with one change. I zested the whole grapefruit, finely chopped about 1Tb of the zest, and, with my fingers, rubbed it in the sugar to try to break the skin and release some of the flavor oils (I’ve done this with compound butter).

    The butter & sugar were creamed with the zest. The results were pretty spot on.

  10. Laura Harley says:

    Absolutely loved this recipe. The flavours were amazing. The cake was a bit more dense than I would have liked but so yummy! It was so nice to celebrate my dear friend Kim’s birthday with our small circle of friends. Gave me a chance to break out the baking tools to play with my Russian icing tips and cake airbrush. So much fun! As always I like to experiment with new recipes on my friends but luckily this gorgeous cake went down well! (especially with some champagne). Wish I could share a picture as it was gorgeous!

  11. I had fun with this recipe! Super delicious! Do you have a video on how to make it? There were parts where I struggled a little. It definitely helped making the curd and icing a day ahead! The cake was dense, but still good. Also, how did you get the icing color to have the pink ombre. Mine looked like pink and white tie dye haha.

    1. I used light pink food gel, added it to 1 cup buttercream and used that to frost the bottom half.

  12. I haven’t tried this yet, but it sounds so amazing!!! I have a question regarding the curd. I’ve never heard of adding cornstarch. Is that because it wouldn’t thicken without it? Does grapefruit juice thicken differently than lemon?

    1. Yes it helps thicken it!

  13. Megan Olson says:

    2 stars
    I wanted so badly to love this cake. It’s pretty, it sounds cool, and grapefruit doesn’t show up in cake very often!

    But when it came down to it, it was utterly ordinary, flavor-wise. Crunchy white cake, generically citrusy curd, and barely-cream cheese American buttercream. The recipes were fine, but the resulting combo just didn’t sing. The grapefruit juice in the cake was imperceptible. (And getting wet poppy seeds off a paper towel is a task I never want to repeat.) The cook times on the curd were far too long for my kitchen and the grapefruit flavor from the fresh squeezed fruits was just too dilute to make much of an impact. And the frosting was just… Fine.

    Not the cake for me, unfortunately. On to the next one!

  14. 5 stars
    Cake texture was so light and delicate.

  15. Any issue with leaving out the poppy seeds? Thanks!

  16. 3 stars
    This recipe makes a wonderfully soft and light cake! However, the flavor just isn’t there. I struggle to find any grapefruit flavor at all. I bet using lemon instead like some have suggested would be very tasty! Or perhaps adding some lemon zest would help up the citrus flavor.

  17. Carol Anne says:

    I love the whole idea of making a grapefuit cake. I love citrus of ANY kind and for summer I want to try every recipe I can think of to celebrate this love! Everyone I come into contact with will be getting some of my baking!
    I think this recipe sounds fantastic, but the exception I will use is the butter will be replaced with canola oil. To do this usually it is a good idea to replace 3/4 butter with oil.
    I have learned over much trial and error and study that oil based cake is soooooo much moister than butter. Time and time again I have made beautiful cakes so amazingly moist and rich using oil.I even make an old recipe handed down from my mom for poppy seed chiffon cake that is out of this world moist and delicious. And so many more times I made butter based cake that just dry out and if they are not eaten in a day they are pushed aside.
    I just made a strawberry lemonade cake that is so beautiful and also is oil based that will be shared with grandkids and family this weekend! I can’t wait to hear what they think!
    Thankyou and I look forward to trying this lovely recipe!

  18. 4 stars
    The texture of this cake is amazing. Firm, yet spongey. The only reason I only gave it 4 stars is because we didn’t care for the grapefruit flavor. The curd was too tart and somewhat bitter. Overall, not our favorite flavor, but still a solid cake recipe. I followed all the recommendations for a moist cake and it came out beautifully. I did use cake strips on my pans and I think that helped, too. Thanks for a great recipe, Courtney!

    1. 5 stars
      I have to update my review. This cake is amazing. Once we got used to the grapefruit, we couldn’t get enough. I am going to try it with lemon. So good!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *