Classic Carrot Cake – deliciously moist spiced carrot cake layers with a perfectly tangy cream cheese buttercream.
Carrot Cake: The Easter Dessert
Hard to believe Easter is less than a week away, right?! What better way to celebrate than with my Classic Carrot Cake recipe. I know this Easter will look a bit different for most of us than in years past, but the meaning stays the same… as do the desserts!
For me, carrot cake is the quintessential Easter dessert. In fact, I think Easter is the only time of year we ever had carrot cake. But here’s the thing – I never liked carrot cake. Not until I made my Carrot Cake with White Chocolate Buttercream, that is. Every carrot cake I ever had growing up had nuts and raisins in it. And I think you know how I feel about that: eew, gross!
But when I made my first carrot cake, based off a Sweetapolita recipe, I realized two things: one, carrot cake doesn’t HAVE to have nuts and raisins and two, carrot cake is actually really good!
Untraditional Recipe
The first carrot cake I published on my blog is definitely untraditional, and I think that’s why I like it so much. My recipe is based off a compilation of a couple adapted recipes from some of my fave bakers: the cake is adapted from Rosie of Sweetapolita and the white chocolate pretzel crack filling is adapted from Christina Tosi of Milk Bar.
I was first attracted to Rosie’s carrot cake because it didn’t have any nuts and raisins, and because she used ginger! I love ginger! Also, I love adding texture to my cakes, but not in the cake layers. So adding Christina’s white chocolate pretzel crack filling was almost a no-brainer.
In addition to the cake and the filling, I decided to add an apricot compote (you can also use apricot jam) and a white chocolate buttercream. Again, I was purposely going against the norm.
The result, a deliciously unique and moist carrot cake!
Classic Carrot Cake
And while I absolutely love that unique carrot cake, I’ve been feeling for a while now that a classic, more traditional carrot cake was calling my name. So, here we are! Today I’m sharing my new Classic Carrot Cake recipe with you.
Traditional Ingredients
Spices
- This carrot cake is more traditional in flavor with spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves.
Oil and Applesauce
- I also use a combination of oil and applesauce for fat and to create a beautiful moist cake. You can certainly use all oil in place of applesauce or sub the applesauce for crushed pineapple.
Freshly Grated Carrots
- It’s SUPER important to use FRESHLY grated carrots in your carrot cake recipes. Freshly grated carrots have more moisture than the pre-shredded carrots. We want a moist cake! That moisture also means the carrot pieces will soften. If you use pre-shredded carrots, you’ll have crunchy carrot pieces in your cake.
Cream Cheese Buttercream
- Sticking to traditional elements, I’m using a cream cheese buttercream with my Classic Carrot Cake instead of my white chocolate buttercream. To ensure the cream cheese flavor doesn’t overpower the cake, I don’t use a lot of cream cheese – just enough to give it a perfectly tangy but not overwhelming cream cheese flavor. See my frequently asked questions about how to get the best frosting results.
Nuts and Raisins
- As I mentioned above, I left nuts and raisins out of my cake layers. However, that doesn’t mean you have to if you love that kind of texture in your classic carrot cake. If you want to add nuts and raisins, I’d start with a half cup of each.
Carrot Cake Cupcakes
If you’d like to turn this Carrot Cake recipe into cupcakes, no problem! A full batch of the batter will make about 24 to 26 standard size cupcakes. You can also split the batch and make a half batch. I did that with my cupcakes yesterday!
For carrot cake cupcakes, you’ll want to bake at 325 degrees F. for a little less time than the cake recipe calls for. Mine were perfect and moist at 20 minutes. If you’re doing a full batch, and baking two cupcake pans at a time (on the same rack), the bake time will vary slightly. Keep your eye on them, but know they’ll take a few minutes longer.
BAKING TIP: I don’t ever recommend baking cake layers or cupcakes on different racks. You always want to bake them on your middle rack. If you can’t fit all of your cake pans or cupcake pans on the same rack in your oven, it’s ok to leave cake batter on the counter while you wait to bake. Just make sure to cover the cake pan or cupcake pan with plastic wrap while you wait.
Could I use this same recipe in a 9×13 pan??
Yes. Just reduce oven temp to 325 and bake for an additional 10-15 minutes. Keep your eye on it!
OMG! Made this cake recipe today. Super easy to follow and it’s delicious! Thank you for sharing!
So glad you loved it!
What cake scraper did you use? I love the shape!
It’s from my store. Shop.cakebycourtney.com
I followed the recipe exactly and the cake was beautifully moist, but it was very bland. The spices don’t come through very well. I’m going to try again using more spices, bc I really want to love this recipe!
Shoot. I haven’t heard that! you are welcome to try doubling the spices and see how it tastes!
Could this be done as cupcakes?
Yes!
did you use dark or light brown sugar on this one?!
light
Is there a way to make this cake smaller for less people?
You could half the recipe and use 2 6-inch pans.
Courtney can you tint this cream cheese buttercream ?
Sure!
Made this cake yesterday and it was Fabulous!!! Baked up with thick moist layers, yummy spices. Everyone loved it. I added a little more cream cheese to the frosting, because that’s how I like it. And drizzled Courtney’s salted carmel over the top! So good!
Yum sounds so good!
Hi! Is there a way to make this for 3 6 inch pans?
thanks!
My recipes are for 3 8-inch or 4-6 inch. You could just leave one of the pans out.
Absolutely delightful. I made this gluten-free and used coconut sugar instead of white and brown sugar, It was amazing. Also, room temperature ingredients really do make a difference in how the cakes rise, thank you for the tip!
Thank you so much!
Courtney, does this buttercream crust over? My family dislikes crusting buttercream, any suggestions? Thank you.
My buttercream does not crust.
Hi Courtney!
Once the buttercream icing is on the cake – does this cake need to be refrigerated or can it stay at room temperature?
Thank you 🙂
It can stay at room temp for a day or two but I suggest freezing leftovers to keep them fresh!
Hey just wondering if I can substitute the flour for gluten free flour to make it a gluten free carrot cake? Thanks 😊
Of course!
I’ve made this before and it was AMAZING!!! My sister is now requesting this cake but vegan, so what could I substitute in place of egg? Thank you
Check out what I used in my egg free vanilla cake!
Super SUPER moist and the consistency of the cupcake is fabulous!! I would suggest upping the spices because they didn’t pull trough very well.
Hi Courtney,
I’ve never made one of your cakes but I’ve been a huge fan since I’ve eaten 3 of the cakes my sister has made following your recipes. I most recently had her make your yellow cake for my 40th birthday and it was the best yellow cake of my life – no small feat considering my childhood love of yellow box cakes. I wanted to make the carrot cake and wondered about adding raisins and nuts to the cake. Any suggestions on what to do different if I add these ingredients? I love traditional carrot cake with all the textures so I’m for sure going to pineapple instead of applesauce as you had in the recipe.
Many thanks!
Aaron
Just toss them in a little bit of flour so they don’t fall to the bottom and enjoy!!
This recipe is so fabulous and was just what I was looking for! I made it gluten free with Cup4Cup and halved it for a three tier 6″, adding a bit more cream cheese to the buttercream. My family all said it was the best carrot cake they ever had! Thank you, Courtney xoxo
I love that!
I substituted gluten free flour in this recipe. It was a very very light cake, even to the point of making it difficult to cut (3 – 8″ pans). I have never had this issue with any other cakes I have used rice flour in, but then I usually bake them in a 9×13 pan. Carrot cake is usually more dense, so I was surprised that it was so light. Using regular white or cake flour, would the cake have been more dense?
A little bit more dense yes. There shouldn’t be any issues cutting it with regular flour.