Easy Baking Substitutions

March 24, 2020

Easy Baking Substitutions – today’s post is all about my favorite baking substitutions, specifically for cakes!

Easy Baking Substitutions

I think this post is long-overdue, but one that couldn’t be more timely! With everyone stocking up on emergency preparedness items, some of our favorite baking ingredients are hard to find on store shelves right now. It’s ok, though! We’re going to do our best to keep baking and work with substitutions, if we have to.

I say, if we have to, because, of course, it’s always best to use the exact ingredients a recipe calls for. However, desperate times, call for desperate measures. If you’re in a pinch, I’d rather you use sub than not bake at all!

Common Baking Substitutions for cakes! #cakebycourtney #cake #baking #bakingsubstitutions

Make sure to download and print the PDF above so you always have these ingredient alternatives on hand when you’re baking. And if you need even more substitution ideas, check out this post from Real Simple. You’ll find extra substitutions for other baking items needed for cookies, brownies, etc.

Other Helpful Baking Posts

And to make sure you’re ready and prepped to get baking, check out these posts:

Some of My Favorite, Easy Cakes

If you’re worried about having hard-to-find ingredients on-hand, consider making some of my easy, classic cakes so you don’t have to reach for any baking substitutions:

Because everyone deserves to have cake – no celebration needed!

Join the Conversation

  1. Heather Bodily says:

    Thank you for this timely substitution list! I was going to make my own birthday cake (using one of your recipes), but because of COVID-19, I couldn’t get my hands on buttermilk or heavy cream! Well, my birthday has come and gone, but yesterday, I was able to find those ingredients. Yay! So, yesterday I heard David Butler mention the idea of making a cake for general conference- to celebrate the birthday of the First Vision. So, cake making is back on! We will make one of your cakes and celebrate on Sunday the 200th anniversary of the First Vision. Thanks for all you do to brighten our world. 🙂

    1. Amazing! I’m so glad!

  2. Hey Courtney!
    For the heavy cream, buttermilk, and sour cream, would almond milk/yogurt or another non-dairy substitute always work like you have in your non-dairy recipies? Thank you!

    1. Yes you can do half milk half yogurt of whatever you like.

  3. Hey, many of the recipes call for with egg yolks or egg whites and I was wondering whether there were any substitutes for this please?
    I have tried apple sauce, mashed bananas, flax seed etc but have not been able to find a good enough alternative? I was wondering if you could help? Thank you

    1. I would look at my vegan cake posts for ideas!

  4. Hey, thank you for this. I was wondering what the replacement for egg yolks would be? And what the replacement would be for egg whites? Many of your lovely recipes involve these ingredients and it would be great if there were substitutes for these as well as the egg substitute you have mentioned? Thank you

    1. Go check out my vegan cake posts. I talk about egg replacements there.

  5. Is your frosting buttercream or fondant? It is so smooth.

  6. Is there a substitution for egg whites? my daughter is allergic to eggs.

    1. Check out my egg free cake!

  7. Shelby Elrod says:

    Do you ever used carton egg whites? I feel guilty just dumping the yolk of eggs when it calls for large amounts of egg whites. Suggestions?

    1. You totally can!

  8. Alicia Pettry says:

    What can I sub milk powder with? Don’t have any on hand, thanks!

    1. There’s no sub.

  9. Can these cakes be made gluten free ?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *