Pumpkin Pie Cake – six pumpkin cake layers with toasted marshmallow filling, pumpkin pie filling, shortbread crumbs and vanilla buttercream.
Cake for Thanksgiving
As most of you know by know, I’m not the biggest fan of pie. I know it’s shocking to some of you. And I’m pretty sure it breaks my mom’s heart every time I say those words. She spent hours teaching me how to make the perfect pie crust when I was growing up. And for pie crust, hers is definitely the best, but I just can’t get on board.
I just accepted that I wouldn’t eat dessert at Thanksgiving dinner 🙂 But then, a few years ago, I tried Sweetapolita’s Autumn Delight Cake and instantly fell in love with the fall inspired flavors. I immediately thought it would be the perfect cake to serve at a Thanksgiving dinner! And so, I did it. I replaced pie with cake and it was the best Thanksgiving ever!
Pie Inspired Cakes
I later tried Milk Bar’s Pumpkin Pie Cake and Apple Pie Cake and became the biggest fan of pie-inspired cake. This year, I decided it was high-time I came up with my own recipes. For my pie-inspired cakes, I took inspiration from three family recipes: my mom’s Apple Pie and Ryan’s mom’s Triple Chocolate Pecan Pie and her Pumpkin Pie. In each of my new recipes, I’ve incorporated the fillings from each of these three family favorites.
Pumpkin Pie Cake
First up, is my Pumpkin Pie Cake. Out of the three (Pumpkin Pie Cake, French Apple Pie Cake and Triple Chocolate Pecan Pie Cake), this one is my favorite! I’ve split three layers of pumpkin cake into six thin layers to maximize the amount of fillings I can add to the cake. I then used toasted marshmallow filling, Ryan’s mom’s pumpkin pie filling and a shortbread crumb to fill each layer. The cake is then covered in a vanilla buttercream.
Make sure to fill your fork with both the pumpkin pie layer and the toasted marshmallow layer so you get the entire experience with each bite. It’s the best form of pumpkin pie I’ve ever had, if I do say so myself 😉
Here’s a short video to show you how I’ve assembled the cake.
I’m so excited for you to make this cake! It’s definitely the one I’ll be making for Thanksgiving dinner at my house.
I CAN NOT wait to make this recipe, Courtney! It sounds amazing! Adding it to my line up for my next family dinner! Thank you!
Hi Courtney!
When I found this recipe I was SO excited because I’ve never seen anything like it! I am in the process of making it right now for a “Friendsgiving” tomorrow. I just wanted to confirm that after making the pumpkin pie filling, you mix it in an air tight container and store in in the fridge overnight? Also, would you recommend wrapping the cake layers in plastic wrap and placing them in the fridge overnight until I assemble the layers tomorrow? Thanks so much! Can’t wait to try it when its done!!
Chloé
Yes, mix the filling and store it in the fridge. And then yes, wrap the cake layers and refrigerate overnight.
I need to know the rest of the instructions for putting this cake together. After number 6 cannot read. I have been on my tablet, iPhone and computer-no luck. Will not show the rest of instructions.
Also, do you add orange gel to make buttercream frosting? Do not see mention of that in frosting instructions. Please get back to me. Thank you!!
I’m not sure what’s going on there. I will figure it out but there’s actually nothing past 6 – just finish frosting the cake. I did add a little orange to my buttercream.
LOOKS DELICIOUS! i THINK I WILL BE MAKING THIS FOR MY FRIENDS GIVING DINNER THIS WEEK. I DO HAVE A QUESTION THOUGH. I AM A LITTLE CONFUSED ON THE PUMPKIN PIE FILLING. CAN YOU EXPLAIN A LITTLE MORE ON IT. THE LAST SENTENCE OF THE DIRECTIONS CONFUSED ME (MOVE TO AIR TIGHT CONTAINER,MIX?…). WHEN IT IS BAKED IS THIS SOME TYPE OF PUDDING CONSISTENCY?
Yes, after it bakes in the pan, let it cool a bit and then you’ll want to chill it before you spread it in the cake. If you see my video, you’ll notice it’s easy to spread like a pudding (but more stable).
I was wondering why the frosting looks like you added coloring to it? Is this vanilla buttercream? And this cake looks amazing BTW
I added “pumpkin” colored food gel.
I’m in the process of making this cake right now, and every has smelled (and tasted) delicious so far. One quick note, though, I did not have enough cake batter to make 3 thick 8 inch layers. I was able to make two 1″ inch thick layers and one 1/2″ thick layer. I’m hoping my one inch layer will cut through okay despite not being super thick! I followed the directions to a tee, so not totally sure why I didn’t yield enough. Still exciting about putting this thing together in the next couple of days!!
Hmm, that’s so strange. My pumpkin cake layers usually rise a bit above 1″. Sorry that wasn’t the case for you. Is your baking powder fresh?
Courtney, could this cake be assembled in its entirety days in advanced and then frozen? I wondered if the freezing might alter the consistency of the marshmallow filling and/or the pie filling. Thanks in advance. I’m stoked to make this cake.
Actually, no, it won’t affect the texture and flavor. I have done it with this cake already and it’s great. I recommend freezing it for an hour initially and then wrapping it entirely in plastic wrap (tightly too). The night before you want to serve it, put it in the fridge and then room temp the next day.
I am committed to making this for Thanksgiving dinner. I know my family will love it! However, I have not been able to find pumpkin purée. Is it possible to make it myself out of canned pumpkin? Also, I need to make a bit smaller cake. Would you recommend making half of the recipe to get a smaller cake? If not, any other recommendations?
Yes, canned pumpkin is the same. And yes, you can cut in half for a 6″ cake
I am going to attempt this for thanksgiving! But I’m scared of doing the 6 layers. The 3 layers are fairly delicate but going even thinner scares me. Any tips on preventing the cake from falling apart when trying to assemble?
Ok, so what I do, is divide my layers but keep them stacked and wrap them to freeze them so they are more firm to move around and stack the cake with. I also use a cake leveler to level the cakes and then a cake lifter (which is like a giant spatula) to move them as I stack the cake. Hopefully that makes sense.
Thankyou! Also, is the shortbread crumb recipe correct? Should it have sugar in it?
i have made a few cake by courtney recipes and they have all been amazing! this recipe was pretty disappointing though. i made it ON thanksgiving (it took 3+ hours) and the cake was just fine. i would have been happy to bake for that long (while my family was all waiting…) if the cake was incredible, but the only adjective that came to mind when i took a first bite was that it was “fine.” two stars because the toasted marshmallow frosting was really yummy contrasted with the rich and spicy pumpkin flavors, but there just wasn’t enough of it when assembled according to instructions to redeem this cake. if you looooove pumpkin (and i list myself in that category), it might be worth a shot, but be aware that you will be baking for a very long time.
Hi Dani, I’m so sorry you were unhappy with the cake. It’s gotten so many good reviews and is one of my personal favorites! Yes, this cake does take some time to make. I do include that time in the instructions and if you’re following me on instagram and my blog, you’ll see that I often suggest making cake layers and certain fillings ahead of time so there’s not too much stress the day of assembly. I’m glad to hear you’ve enjoyed some of my other cakes and I hope you’ll continue to try many more. xx-Courtney
Courtney I just came across this wonderful looking cake, read the recipe….and was hooked !!! I will be making this for our prayer meeting this Friday night…. I’m sure this will be a keeper !!! Thanks for sharing !!!!
Is there no sugar in the short bread crumb recipe???
Do you think I could substitute the heavy cream for coconut cream?
Yes just make sure you are using the thickest coconut cream.
This looks divine! Will it be okay to make the night before and leave out?
I would keep it in the fridge overnight!
I’m so excited to make this cake for thanksgiving! Your website and Instagram have been such a help as I’m starting to bake cakes. A couple questions: 1) in the video I see that you pipe around the edges on some layers-is that with the buttercream frosting? If so, Will there be enough frosting to do that, and to frost the whole cake? 2) should I add sugar to the shortbread crumbs, or should I leave the sugar out of it? Thank you so much!
Yes there’s enough frosting. And don’t add sugar to the pie crumbs.
Hi,
Thank you for this recipe. It sounds amazing. I am assuming I should store the pumpkin pie filling in the refrigerator over night? Can you please clarify this for me? Thanks so much!
Yes store it overnight in the fridge!