The Most Delicious German Chocolate Cake

German Chocolate Cake – Rich, dark chocolate cake layers, filled with a buttery, toasted coconut filling and pecan wafer crunch, topped with a classic chocolate buttercream.

German Chocolate Cake #cakebycourtney #germanchocolatecake #chocolatecake #chocolatefrosting #milkbar #cake #easychocolatecake

Converted

I never thought I’d say this about a German Chocolate Cake, but I’m so excited about this cake! I’ll be honest, it’s one cake I’ve never understood the hype about. I know some people love it, but I just couldn’t jump on the bandwagon. For me, the texture of the pecans and raw coconut were an immediate turn off. I’ve also never tried a German Chocolate Cake that had decent chocolate cake layers. They always seem bland and dry.

I ended up making this cake because a good friend told me it was her husband’s favorite and asked if I’d come up with a recipe for it. Of course I accepted the challenge 😉

Inspiration from the One and Only

I just knew, however, that I needed to make some changes to the classic version. I started to look around at recipes and didn’t see anything that really caught my attention until I turned to Milk Bar, one of my favorite bakeries in New York City. (They share a few of their recipes online, but you need the cookbook to get ALL the good stuff.)
German Chocolate Cake #milkbar
Picture source: Popsugar
 
Per usual, Christina Tosi went off the beaten path and created a unique twist on an old classic (which they actually call “German Chocolate Jimbo Cake”). Christina’s version has layers of chocolate cake, chocolate malt soak, chocolate fudge sauce, crack pie filling, coconut, pecan wafer crunch and chocolate malt frosting. Sounds pretty incredible, right?!
 
While all of these elements make my heart skip a beat with pure joy, I didn’t think my cake needed to be this extravagant. Instead, I took inspiration from Christina’s cake and came up with my own version.
 

My German Chocolate Cake

My starting point for this cake, and any chocolate cake I make, was my dark chocolate cake. I know most people like milk chocolate cake layers for a German Chocolate Cake, but I’m just not a fan. Dark chocolate has such a rich flavor and is never too sweet.
 
I also used my chocolate buttercream in this cake. It’s a classic I can’t live without.
German Chocolate Cake #cakebycourtney #chocolatecake #germanchocolatecake
 
From Christina’s cake, I loved the idea of the coconut and pecan fillings – just not with raw coconut and pecans. So, I toasted my coconut and used the Milk Bar “crack” pie filling. It’s so good! I suggest making a double batch. You’ll be snacking on this all day! (It’s actually a great apple dip!)
 
I was also blown away with the pecan crunch filling. Instead of using raw whole pecans, Christina whips up a toasted pecan butter and tosses it with crushed chocolate wafer cookies. So, you still get the nutty flavor without the gritty texture of a raw nut. Perfection!
German Chocolate Cake #cakebycourtney #chocolatecake #germanchocolatecake
 
I really loved how this cake turned out and will be adding it to my list of favorites! Just make sure you have a glass of milk nearby with this one!
 

Other Recipes Like This

https://cakebycourtney.com/cakedecorating101/

German Chocolate Cake

Rich, dark chocolate cake layers, filled with toasted coconut filling and pecan wafer crunch, topped with a classic chocolate buttercream.

Edit Recipe Delete Recipe

Courtney Rich

I’m a self-taught baker, obsessed with cake.

I long ago ditched box mixes in pursuit of melt-in-your-mouth, to-die-for flavor combinations, fillings and textures. I believe cake must be decadent, life-changing and worthy of celebration! And I believe anyone should be able to bake that kind of cake – and I’m here to teach you just that!

Get my free cake decorating guide
Everything you need to know about decorating a cake like a pro!

You Might Also Like

Leave a Comment

Comments

  1. Oh, gosh, so many things I’m not doing right. I assumed 9×13 glass dish and my crack pie is taking forever to bake. Did I ruin it? It also took forever to toast my sweetened coconut. I gave up before it reached the brown I was thinking of. Is there hope?

    1. Milk powder can be found at the grocery store in the baking aisle. And the chocolate wafers can really be any brand you find. I’ve tried a few and don’t have a preference.

    1. Really any kind will work. I don’t have a specific brand I have to have for the cake. The Nabisco ones will work great.

  2. The crack filling is taking me over double the time you said, is that ok? I’m using a glass dish, does that make a difference?

    1. Yes that’s ok. How are your cakes cooking? If those are taking longer than my suggested time too, you may have to check your oven temperature. It may be running cooler than it tells you on the screen.

  3. I’ve made your delicious cakes and they always turned out perfect, but I’m not sure about the coconut crack in this recipe. After about 13 minutes I removed it from the oven and the butter appeared to separate from the rest of the mixture. I mixed it with a spatula and then it looked OK. Should I try again prior to adding the coconut? Was the baking at 325 degrees so the eggs were cooked?

  4. Hi Courtney,I stumbled upon your website while idly surfing through Instagram and boy, am I glad I did! Your flavor combinations are just brilliant and very innovative. I saw your post on the german chocolate cake and I just had to see your filling recipe. I’m not sure if we get grapeseed oil in this part of the world (I live in the Middle east). So I was wondering if you could suggest me a substitute for this oil?

  5. THIS sounds amazing! My very first cake was a German chocolate cake for my grandpas birthday since it’s his fave, I should try this one out for him too!

  6. A few questions on the German chocolate cake recipe…. is milk powder the same as powdered milk? Also, the chocolate wafer cookies, are those the ones with the waffle like print on them? Or are they something else? Thanks!

  7. Should the pecan crunch be really salty? Also, the coconut crack has hardened… should it be gooey? Thinking I should try them both again. Oh boy! 😉

    1. Yes the pecan crunch is salty – it balances all the sweet really well once they are all together. And just microwave the coconut filling for 10-20 seconds to soften it to put in the cake.

  8. This looks amazing 😍 is there any substitution for grape seed oil in making the pecan butter?? I’m in a pinch and can’t get any.

  9. I made this and it was absolutely divine! Thank you!! I think the fillings were too much in quantity (esp the coconut crack). I don’t feel that I got enough chocolate cake in one bite. I might increase the cake or decrease the coconut crack next time.

  10. This cake was soooooo delicious!! From the sweet and salty filling to the texture of cake with a crunchy filling. Oh my! I’ve made a few of your recipes and this was a huge hit with my family and friends. Everyone agreed this is their fav. recipe so far. Thank you so much for sharing!

  11. What type of milk powder do you use for this? Instant skim milk powder or non instant whole milk powder?

  12. Hey Courtney! I have a friend wanting me to make a GCC for her dads birthday and this looks SO good!! One question, why AP flour for this and not cake flour? Thanks!!

  13. Can this cake be completed and refrigerated or frozen for a day or two or will the layers get soggy with the fillings?

    So far all the different steps have turned out so tasty!

  14. Can’t wait to try this! Couple of questions…are the wafer cookies the rectangular ones with the chocolate cream filling or just thin chocolate cookies? Also, when you pull the filling out and add the coconut, do you mix it up and then spread it out to cool. Trying to figure out the consistency of it. Thank you!

    1. The rectangle ones with the filling! And just mix in the coconut and the filling is ready to go. You don’t need to spread it.

      1. Thank you! Do you think I could use coconut oil in place of the grape seed oil? I appreciate all your help. Can’t wait to taste it!

  15. Just got through with baking the cake layers, but they only rose about half as tall as I see in the photos. I used three 8” pans, and had fresh baking powder too. Not sure what I did wrong, but it smells incredible. Just won’t have much cake scraps after leveling 😅

  16. Hi there! I have a question about the chocolate wafer cookies used in your German Chocolate Cake. Are you talking about the rectangular wafer cookies that come in strawberry, chocolate, and vanilla flavors? Or is it the little circular vanilla wafer cookies that also come in chocolate flavor? Hope that makes sense. TIA!

  17. Hi!!! Love love love your recipes! And I appreciate you responding to all questions out there 🙂
    Few questions for you… How long will the cake layers last in the fridge wrapped in plastic foil? If frozen, how long would it take to thaw for a 6in cake? One fully assembled and frosted, how long will the cake last in the fridge? Thank you!!!

    1. Double wrap them in saran and they can be in there for months! Once assembled, you don’t want to keep it in the fridge for more than a day or it will dry out.

  18. Hi! Do you think I could add some rum to the crack filling?? If so, how much should I add?
    My brother is wanting some rum incorporated haha
    Thanks!

  19. I have a couple of questions. Is there any malt in this or was that just the example of another cake you like? Can I use malt powder in place of powdered milk? Also do I just use coconut from the package or do I need to toast it in the oven before I add it to the filling? I’m super excited to make this. I made your chocolate chip cookie cake for my birthday and it was amazing.

    1. There is no malt in this! And I would toast the coconut so its more crunchy instead of chewy and has that yummy toasted taste!

  20. I also have another question. What is the texture of the coconut filling supposed to be like? Is it supposed to be smooth with only the texture of the coconut? Mine is sugary and grainy because the sugar crystallized. Is that right?

      1. I have the same issue with my coconut crack- this is the 3rd time I’ve made it and each time it has a grainy texture. Is that correct?

  21. I have a question about the coconut crack, when you add in the coconut, do you stir it in and what consistency should it be when cooled? Is it like a spread? I can’t wait to make this for my dad’s birthday! Thanks!

  22. Hi, Courtney!

    I made this cake over the weekend and it turned out great. I had to make a couple of adjustments. The baking time for the cake appears to be incorrect. I typically bake an eight inch layer cake 28-30 minutes at 350 degrees. Also, both fillings seemed to have a little to much salt. I will adjust the amount of salt next time.

  23. Hello! This looks yummy! I noticed that in a lot of your cakes you use cake flour. Is there a reason this one does not? If I were to use cake flour instead, what alterations to the recipe would need to be made? Thanks for your help and your fabulous recipes!!!

  24. Courtney, Nabisco has stopped making their chocolate wafers.
    Would thin Oreos be a good substitute? Thank you.

  25. I noticed this cake recipe is slightly different from your chocolate cake recipe. When comparing this cake ingredients to the chocolate cake ingredients, everything is the same except for the flour and sugar. Is it correct to use 1 3/4 cups flour vs 2 cups of flour? Also, do we use 2 cups sugar vs 1 3/4 cups sugar?

  26. I am ready to learn once I seen these recipes this is fantastic you are doing a fantastic job and I’m ready and I’m calling I’m from Houston Texas

  27. This was truly SO delicious! I used this cake recipe to pair with a family member’s German chocolate frosting recipe and it was perfect! It’s somehow the perfect texture, being both dense and light at the same time. And so moist! I’ll certainly be making again and using Courtney’s cake recipes in the future!